The Black Dog Nobody Noticed

Oftentimes, when dogs get picked up by animal control and end up in an unfamiliar kennel, they’ll feel extremely fearful. Some sensitive dogs just need a second chance — someone to look past their initial fearful reactions and give them a moment to feel safe. That’s exactly what happened with Vinny.

When Vinny was initially found by the Maricopa County Animal Shelter in Arizona, he was abandoned alongside three other dogs in a rental home with no food or water. “Vinny was in an open crate where everybody was walking by, and he was growling at everyone,” his pet parent, Robin, says. But that fearful reaction didn’t deter them. They asked for a meet-and-greet.

Courtesy Vinny’s person/

Black dogs face a harder time being adopted

While waiting, Robin learned something they hadn’t known before. “The shelter volunteer said, ‘I’m really glad you’re giving him a second look, because he’s all black — and sometimes all-black dogs kind of get forgotten about in the shelter.’”

This is a well-documented phenomenon often referred to as “black dog syndrome” — the observation that black dogs tend to wait longer for adoption and, as a result, face higher euthanasia rates than lighter-colored dogs. Researchers and animal welfare workers have pointed to a few possible factors for this: Black dogs can sometimes be harder to photograph well, and they may appear more imposing or harder to read emotionally. 

Thanks to awareness campaigns from shelters and rescue organizations, the outlook isn’t as grim anymore for dogs with darker coats. Still, in some regions, especially for organizations with significant overcrowding, this can remain a problem. 

Related article

Why You Should Adopt a Black Dog

Whether we’ve overcome black dog syndrome or not, plenty of black shelter dogs still need loving homes.

Finding the perfect match

After learning about this phenomenon, Robin went to the meet-and-greet area. “He jumped right [on] my lap and literally the rest is history,” Robin says. “He stole our hearts.” 

Dogs who’ve been through trauma rarely make the leap to home life without some bumps. Robin’s family has been putting in the work, helping Vinny work through his fears and anxiety at his own pace. The progress has been remarkable. “He is such a sensitive, sweet guy — a total love bug. He gets along with his new brother and sisters, too,” Robin says.

What Robin describes when she talks about Vinny isn’t just a happy adoption story. It’s a reminder of what’s possible when someone decides to give a pup a chance. “To us, Vinny encompasses the journey of a shelter pup,” Robin says, “going through terrible times, then finding his forever home and thriving.”